Home Page Link AgBioWorld Home Page
About AgBioWorld Donations Ag-Biotech News Declaration Supporting Agricultural Biotechnology Ag-biotech Info Experts on Agricultural Biotechnology Contact Links Subscribe to AgBioView Home Page

AgBioView Archives

A daily collection of news and commentaries on

Subscribe AgBioView Subscribe

Search AgBioWorld Search

AgBioView Archives





August 10, 2000


organic / pesticide residues - who is out-spinning whom ??


August 8, 2000
N.Y. Times/AP

ABC News was cited as saying yesterday that a report challenging the assumed
benefits of organic food was partly based on research that did not exist and
that it would make a correction on Friday nightšs "20/20" program.

In the report, the correspondent John Stossel said research commissioned by
ABC News showed that conventional produce did not necessarily have more
pesticide residue than did organic produce.

"Our tests, surprisingly, found no pesticide residue on the conventional
samples or the organic," he said in the report first broadcast on Feb. 8 and
again on July 7.

But the two researchers who were commissioned to do the testing -- Dr.
Michael Doyle, a scientist with the University of Georgia, and Dr. Lester
Crawford, director of the Center for Food and Nutrition Policy at
Georgetown University -- said they had never tested produce for pesticide
residue for ABC.

In a statement released last night, ABC was cited as confirming that
pesticide tests were never performed on produce. But it steered blame away
from Mr. Stossel, adding, "In making that statement, Mr. Stossel was relying
on inaccurate information that had been provided to him."

Executives said David Fitzpatrick, producer of the segment, was responsible
for the error, and they were trying to determine how it appeared. But, they
said, they believed it was an honest mistake and did not think Mr.
Fitzpatrick would be disciplined. Mr. Stossel will make the correction.

The stories note that problems with the report were first brought to light
by the members of the Environmental Working Group, which supports the
consumption of organic food. They had learned that Mr. Stosselšs assertion
about the pesticide tests was in error after speaking with the researchers.

They apprised Mr. Stossel of their findings in a letter dated Feb. 8. They
were answered by Mr. Fitzpatrick, who, in a letter, asserted that ABC did,
indeed, test produce for pesticide residue. After the report was rerun, Mr.
Stossel re-emphasized the pesticide assertion in an on-the-air conversation
with Cynthia McFadden, a "20/20" anchor.

Executives at ABC, a unit of Walt Disney, said they were trying to determine
why the groupšs assertion about the supposed pesticide tests was not
addressed when it was first raised.

The Environmental Working Group also contended that Mr. Stosselšs report
had inappropriately implied that ABCšs tests had detected dangerous strains
of E. coli bacteria in the organic food when, in fact, the tests did not
establish the presence of the dangerous type of E. coli.

Executives said they were still looking into that accusation.
Kenneth Cook, president of the Environmental Working Group, was cited as
saying that he was not satisfied with ABCšs statement, stating, about
Stossel, "Hešs not a contrarian, hešs a counterfeiter whošll do anything for
ratings. He needs to be fired."


Des D'Souza
Public and Government Affairs Manager
Seed and Crop Improvement
Aventis CropScience UK Ltd.
Fyfield Road,
Ongar,Essex CM5 0HW
E.mail : Des.Dsouza@aventis.com
Office tel: 0044 -(0) 1277-301482
Fax : 0044 - (0) 1277-301509
Pager : 0044 - (0) 7669 004364

> The information transmitted in this e-mail is intended only for the person
> or entity to which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or
> privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other
> use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by
> persons or entities other than the intended recipients is prohibited. If
> you have received this e-mail in error, please contact the sender and
> delete the material from any computer.