AgBioView - http://www.agbioworld.org, http://agbioview.listbot.com
We need data to counter the awful story described below. It went in the
Independent this Sunday, and alleges that Green Revolution crops fail to take up
iron and zinc, thereby affecting the intelligence of millions of rural poor.
This is the most vicious attack on the green revolution I have ever seen. I am
quite sure that it is manifestly wrong, but as the paper is based on a British
Government funded research programme, we will need to address it thoroughly.
My first guess is that the report itself does not come to the horrific
conclusions written in the newspaper article below at all, but we have to know,
so we can react.
Willy Roca, could you send this around through the CGIAR mail network, so that
it can be answered swiftly? I am sure the people in CIMMYT and IRRI have
mountains of material to attack this absurd allegation?
Partha, could you advise the people you know at IRRI about this?
Willy De Greef
"C. S. Prakash" on 05.05.2000 14:01:38
cc: (bcc: Willy DeGreef/SE/Novartis)
Subject: 'Green Revolution' Made us (Literally) Stupid?
To unsubscribe, write to AgBioViewfirstname.lastname@example.org
- http://www.agbioworld.org, http://agbioview.listbot.com
Hi-tech crops are bad for the brain
By Geoffrey Lean, Environment Correspondent
The Independent (UK), 23 April 2000
"Miracle" crops, hailed as the answer to global famine, are contributing to
widespread brain impairment in the developing world, a new report
It says that the high-yielding rice and wheat varieties that brought about
the much-heralded "Green Revolution" are among a range of environmental
factors undermining human intelligence.
The study, which looks at environmental threats to human intelligence, is
part of the £15m Global Environmental Change Programme, financed by
Britain's Economic and Social Research Council. It is published tomorrow.
It concludes that a deadly combination of soil erosion, pollution and
inadequate diet is affecting the intelligence of millions of people, with
effects ranging from severe intellectual disabilities to "sub-clinical
decline" in whole populations.
The Green Revolution crops, introduced in the late 1960s and early 1970s,
produce several times as much grain as the traditional varieties they
replaced, and they spread rapidly. They enabled India to double its wheat
crop in seven years, dramatically increasing food supplies and averting
widely predicted famine.
But the report says that the new crops, unlike their predecessors, fail to
take up minerals such as iron and zinc from the soil. So even as people
consumed more calories, their intake of these key "micronutrients" fell.
"High-yielding Green Revolution crops were introduced in poorer countries
to overcome famine," the report says. "But these are now blamed for causing
intellectual deficits, because they do not take up essential
The report is written by Dr Christopher Williams, a research fellow with
the Global Environmental Change Programme. Using already published UN data
he has calculated that 1.5 billion people ? one quarter of the earth's
population ? are affected by "Green Revolution iron deficiency". He claims
the condition impairs the learning ability of more than half of India's
He concludes that, eventually, the evolution of the brain could go into
reverse as humans develop more extensive digestive systems to cope with the
lack of nutrients ? sacrificing intelligence in the process.
The professor's sources include the Food and Agriculture Organisation of
the United Nations which has compiled evidence that the amount of the metal
in people's diets fell throughout most of the Third World in the 1970s and
1980s, making iron deficiency the only form of malnutrition to increase
over the two decades. The greatest drops in the intake of iron took place
in South and South East Asia, the very areas where the Green Revolution was
Other UN figures show that half the world's pregnant women are anaemic,
because they have too little iron, putting both them and their babies at
risk. The condition is thought to be responsible for 200,000 deaths a year.
And the World Bank reckons that deficiencies of iron, iodine, and vitamin A
together wipe out some 5 per cent of the GDP of developing countries, a
crippling blow to poor economies.
>The web address for this article is: